Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheese Pizza
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Lasagna
Baked Ziti
About
Slice of Italy
If you're in search of authentic Italian flavors that capture the essence of Italy right in Allentown, look no further than Slice of Italy. Located at 5924 Tilghman St, this pizzeria stands out not only for its delightful dishes but also for its welcoming atmosphere and attentive service. Touted as a hidden gem, Slice of Italy has won the hearts of locals with its commitment to quality and taste.
As you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked pizzas envelops you. The menu boasts an enticing array of options, from their inventive Taco Pizza Slice—a delightful blend of steak, mozzarella, and zesty blue cheese dressing—to the comforting Eggplant Parm Pizza Slice, which showcases layers of rich sauce, eggplant, and melty mozzarella. For those seeking a meatier option, the Meat Lover's Pizza Slice is a carnivore's delight, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.
Among the remarkable offerings, the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza stands tall, marrying grilled chicken and bacon with a drizzle of ranch. It's a perfect companion to the Hawaiian Pizza, which features sweet pineapple and tender ham, enhancing the overall taste experience. Venture into their gourmet section, where the Quattro Cheese Pizza entices with its melty blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, and American cheese, inviting you on a cheesy adventure.
What truly sets Slice of Italy apart are the glowing reviews from customers. Regulars rave about the freshness of ingredients, noting that each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. Farroukh Mohammed shared his appreciation for the flexibility in accommodating Halal preferences, while Billie Jean Imani highlighted the exceptional customer service delivered by staff, particularly Sherry N., that made her first visit remarkable.
But it’s not just the pizza that earns high praise; diners like Jason have fondly mentioned the owner, whose 40 years of experience in the restaurant industry clearly shines through in every dish. From the savory Veal Parmesan to the classic Grandma Pizza, there’s no shortage of options that keep patrons coming back for more.
In a region where good pizza can be hard to find, Slice of Italy shines brightly. Whether you're dining in, grabbing a slice to go, or enjoying their offerings for a night in, it’s a delicious escape into the heart of Italian cuisine. At Slice of Italy, every bite is a celebration of flavor, devotion, and an enduring love for pizza that keeps the community returning for more.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I wanna thank the team who works here and their flexibility. We really enjoyed HALAL buffalo chicken pizza. Drop off chicken from next door and they make Halal pizza for you within 30 mins. By far one of the best halal pizzas I had. ”
“ Best Italian spot in town! food was delicious i tried the Lucas Alfredo it was the bomb, its a must try and the pizza is great too, but most importantly i experienced the best customer service and served by Sherry N. she was friendly kind and extremely helpful she made my experience there for the first an unforgettable one I will definitely come back again! thanks again Sherry I hope they know they have a Great one.. you made my day ”
“ The best pizza place by far in Lehigh valley area, the ingredients are always fresh and their sauce is amazing. The staff are nice and quick. My go to place for Italian pizza and pasta, ordering takeout from here 1-2 times a week. My favorites are grandma pizza and buffalo chicken pizza. Strongly recommend! ”
“ Updated below:::Continues to be the best pizza in area even under new ownership. Miss the old crowd but glad to see they kept the quality. From Philadelphia I struggled to find good pizza in area. NY style at its finest. Update- The Lehigh Valley is notorious for blah pizza. Yes been to them all. Slice of Italy continues to produce as close to NYC level pizza in the area. Pictures are worth a thousand words. Look how good! ”
“ Slice of Italy is an amazing place to eat. The owner is genuinely interested in whether you enjoyed your meal or not. It's very obvious that he really cares about each meal that he prepares. I've heard him mention that he's been working in the restaurant business for over 40 years now. It's pretty clear by the quality of each meal he prepares. All of his specialty pizzas are delicious and the prices are reasonable. My two favorite things to get at this restaurant are the Veal Parmesan and the Eggplant Parmesan (with angel hair). Parking is slightly annoying because of the one way parking lot, but if you can't find a spot in front of the restaurant, there are a bunch of spots at the very end of the parking lot. ”
“ If you need a quick slice to fill up for a trip, they got plenty of different slices that you can order. I ordered my go-to yesterday for dinner, as of this review, which was a large cheese pie, well done. They never disappoint, obviously it's not the Costco 10 pie, but this place is worth every penny. It is the best pizzeria at least in the Upper Macungie area. Staff was also super friendly, and are genuinely delighted to serve you. Great place, and I will be a regular because of how close the place is to me. ”
“ Really good pizza. I had a large meat lovers pie with chicken added onto it. Deliciously dangerous as I wanted to eat more than just two slices in one sitting. Easy to order online with alot of selections. First time coming to the place and will be back for more. ”
“ Grandma and Chicken Alfredo pizzas. Always great. ”